Euthanasia Prevention Coalition – Newsweek article: Mass exodus from organ donation registries

Share this article

By: Alex Schadenberg, EPC International Chair, originally published August 13, 2025, Euthanasia Prevention Coalition

The US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) sent out the  following media release  on July 21, 2025 concerning organ donation and the organ transplant system in America.

Health and Human Services examined 351 organ donation approvals and determined that in 103 of the cases the dead donor rule may have been violated. 

Organ donation is a difficult topic to write about since organ donation can save lives. I have  written about issues related to organ donation for many years. It is a scandal that death is sometimes caused by organ removal rather than organs being retrieved from a dead donor.

Since then we have published three articles on the organ donation scandal (
Article 1) ( Article 2) ( Article 3).

Joshua Rhett Miller   reported for Newsweek on August 13  that the recent organ donation articles have led to an unprecedented mass exodus from organ donation registries. Miller wrote:

Thousands of Americans have removed themselves from organ donor registries following “irresponsible reporting” led by the New York Times, officials said.


The Association of Organ Procurement Organizations (AOPO), a trade group that represents 46 of the nation’s 55 federally designated nonprofit entities that help facilitate donations, accused the newspaper of a “lack of balance and accuracy” in its recent coverage of the problems in the sprawling transplant system.

An AOPO letter stated that:

“These stories have directly led to the biggest increase in people removing themselves from donor registries ever recorded, putting patients waiting for transplants at greater risk,”

The AOPO letter claims both articles contained “serious factual inaccuracies.”

Claims about factual inaccuracies don’t negate the reality that the US Health and Human Services examined 351 organ donation approvals and found:

  • 73 patients with neurological signs incompatible with organ donation.
  • At least 28 patients may not have been deceased at the time organ procurement was initiated—raising serious ethical and legal questions.

There were also problems with poor neurologic assessments, lack of coordination with medical teams, questionable consent practices, and misclassification of causes of death, particularly in overdose cases.

In other words, the AOPO should have monitored organ donation programs to prevent the scandal that has occurred. People support the dead donor rule. People are willing to donate their organs once they have died, but they do not want to die by donating their organs.

Last year the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition published an excellent article by lawyer, Sara Buscher titled:  Let’s not get rid of the Dead Donor Rule.

If the Dead Donor Rule is ignored or removed it results in people losing trust in the system and withdrawing their names from organ donation registries.

Alex Schadenberg is the Executive Director of Euthanasia Prevention Coalition.

Recent Posts

By Elise Winland July 7, 2026
By: Elise Winland, originally published July 6, 2026, Zeale News
By N/A N/A July 1, 2026
Granny Bibbins is a popular social media figure with millions of followers. Her no nonsense direct cultural observations on pro-faith and pro-freedom issues are summed up by the tag line, "Make Sense Common Again". Those who enjoy her video commentaries and homespun wisdom shake their heads in agreement with her straightforward analysis and conclusions. Recently, it has come to light that three pieces of “Common Sense” legislation, after passing the Ohio House, will not be voted upon in the Senate, at least until after the November elections and possibly not before the end of the legislative session. The bills which await a vote in the Ohio Senate before receiving the governor's signature are: The Baby Olivia Act (House Bill 485) which would simply assure public schools show a 3 minute, age appropriate video on fetal development in grades 5-12. Common Sense. Patient Protection Act (House Bill 324) requires an 'in person' evaluation before any drug with at least a 5% chance of causing severe adverse effects, including death, sepsis, organ failure, or hospitalization due to infection or hemorrhage can be dispensed. The bill also requires a follow up evaluation to ensure the patient's safety and identify any warning signs of complications. Common Sense. She Wins Act (House Bill 347) seeks to apply to the abortion procedure, the same informed consent protocols applied to any other common medical procedure. Regardless of an individuals’ position on abortion, the bill is predicated on the fact patients deserve complete and accurate information before making a medical decision. Common Sense The reasons why these bills, were not referred to the full Senate for a vote before the Senate summer recess has not been explained. While we wait for an explanation, pro-life supporters should call their Ohio Senator and ask why the Ohio Senate decided to go on a summer 'vacation' before voting to Make Sense Common Again . Ask your Senator, after returning from his or her summer break to vote for : · The Baby Olivia Act (House Bill 485) · The Patient Protection Act (House Bill 324) · The She Wins Act (House Bill 347)  Need your Ohio Senator's contact information? Go to: https://www.legislature.ohio.gov/ and complete "Who Represents Me."
By Melanie Wade June 24, 2026
By: Ryan King, originally published June 22, 2026, The New York Post Golf fans attending the third round of the US Open at Shinnecock Hills Saturday were left stunned when an airplane buzzed the course towing an advertisement promoting obtaining abortion pills by mail. The ad was paid for by Mayday Health, a Massachusetts-based nonprofit dedicated to highlighting the… The post Abortion pill advertisement at US Open leaves golf fans appalled: ‘Gross and divisive’ appeared first on Cincinnati Right to Life.
By Melanie Wade June 12, 2026
By: Amy O’Donnell, originally published June 11, 2026, Society of St. Sebastian For nearly fifty years under Roe v. Wade, abortion was treated as a constitutional right deeply embedded in American law, politics, education, and culture. Organizations like Planned Parenthood aggressively promoted it, especially in low-income and minority communities. Meanwhile, pro-life advocates worked incrementally to save… The post When Protecting Life Loses Its Heart appeared first on Cincinnati Right to Life.
By Melanie Wade June 12, 2026
By: Nancy Flanders, originally published May 15, 2026, LiveAction.org A recent post on X regarding maternal mortality has gone viral, but the post uses a source from nearly two years ago that has already been debunked. Despite this, the misinformation is now making the rounds on social media and has racked up more than 8.7 million views. Yet,… The post Why a viral tweet about maternal mortality shouldn’t be taken as fact appeared first on Cincinnati Right to Life.
By Melanie Wade June 10, 2026
By: Calvin Freiburger, originally published June 5, 2026, LifeSiteNews.com The Trump administration Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has finally begun its review of the data on abortion pill harms, more than a year after the move was promised to frustrated pro-lifers. In May 2025, the Trump administration promised to review abortion pill data, but a year without… The post Trump FDA finally begins abortion pill review after pressure from pro-lifers appeared first on Cincinnati Right to Life.
By Melanie Wade June 5, 2026
By: Mary Rose, originally published June 5, 2026, The Loop/Zeale News. Parents of children with Down syndrome took to X June 4 to share stories of love and advocacy, responding to a viral post by YouTuber Jesse Ridgway in which he announced he and his wife aborted their unborn child after learning the baby had… The post “The happiest people on Earth’: Down syndrome families flood social media after YouTuber aborts baby due to Down syndrome diagnosis appeared first on Cincinnati Right to Life.
By Melanie Wade June 5, 2026
By: Elise Winland, originally published June 4, 2026, The Loop/Zeale News Chloe Cole, a 21-year-old detransitioner, urged Congress during an emotional June 3 hearing to ban gender “transition” procedures for children, alleging that doctors lied to her family and left her with irreversible physical and emotional harm. Cole — who began “transitioning” at age 12… The post Detransitioner Chloe Cole urges Congress to ban gender ‘transition’ procedures for minors during heated Senate hearing appeared first on Cincinnati Right to Life.
By Melanie Wade June 5, 2026
By: Dan Hart, originally published May 27, 2026, The Washington Stand A startling new study has revealed that the vast majority of online abortion drug vendors are shipping the pills to women whose unborn children are past the point of 10 weeks’ gestation, in violation of the FDA’s federal safety limit. The report, released by the… The post Study: 64 Online Abortion Pill Vendors Ignore 10-Week Gestational Limit appeared first on Cincinnati Right to Life.
By Melanie Wade June 3, 2026
Congratulations to the winners of this year’s Pro-Life Poster Contest!! We received 510 submissions! The students very brilliantly depicted this year’s theme “One Nation Under God, Protecting Life For All.” Here are the 20261st, 2nd, & 3rd Place Winners: Thank you to all those who participated!! The post Announcing Cincinnati Right to Life’s 2026 Poster Contest Winners! appeared first on Cincinnati Right to Life.
Show More